-
OK this post is dead but I voted anyway.
(1). I think the attacker should be able to tell his troops to put a castle under siege for so many round but he has to supply food to his troops just like if they where in town.
(2).Its unfair for the defender to have to give up his gold to an army that did not breach his walls. gold should be in a safe some where in the city not falling out of the sky at attackers.
(3).If the defender is getting support the supporters should battle through a siege line both side's taking losses but if attackers win they should get the loot.
(4).warehouses are in the game for a reason but 4 people with maxed privateering could wipe some one out the defender might as well opened his gate.
(5). so in conclusion every thing is evened out attacker's don't get the city if they win but they still get plunder. defenders can get assistance from ally's when ever he wants. even though his gates are closed he still looses
-
-
battle3.evony.com/default.html?logfile/20090801/bd/d6/bdd60a1e85b5756d05c688a7d452b28c.xml
battle3.evony.com/default.html?logfile/20090801/81/b6/81b6bcd75d5aa3bb10511b3e8d217e03.xml
battle3.evony.com/default.html?logfile/20090801/fe/47/fe47fbbde7fe69f7fe8e3044f778ec2c.xml
battle3.evony.com/default.html?logfile/20090801/df/12/df12642f3b88f70df97335c87d62cd35.xml
battle3.evony.com/default.html?logfile/20090801/1e/f5/1ef50906d79da4e8b6e36a0c99d2c9af.xml
enough said
-
I think army limits by rally point is rediculous. A defender can have a million troops, but you can only attack with 125k max. Just rediculous. They really need to drop the army limits imposed by the rally point so this game can be a real war game. Players shouldn't be able to make themself invincible. How many troops would it take to break a million archers with lev.10 wall bonus? Let players attack with a million archers if they can support them!!!
I haven't been attacked once all game. Because it would just be a waste of time. On world 11, having 350k archers/50k ballista makes you pretty much invincible with lev.10 archery and walls. Now, if somebody could attack me with a million troops, I'd have to actually be wary of an attack.
Remove the limit imposed by the rally point and let this game get fun. Let the big guys build up huge attack armies to threaten other big guys!!!! Instead of just having all the big guys attack all the smaller guys because they cannot attack a guy of similiar size without taking 2x-5x more losses..
-
The poll needs a third option. because in my opinion all the advantage is on the offense.
attackers can send wave after wave crushing the defenses far faster than they can ever be rebuilt.
it is nigh impossible to survive against a truly dedicated assault
-
It's like real life. Defendin' is always easier than attackin'.
Defenders always have more advantages.
Warlords can only ever send so many troops at once. Defenders can have their entire force and more sit in one spot and defend.
Attackers don't get protective walls and traps; defenders do (moat around the castle, anyone?)
Defenders get the same access to seige weaponry that attacks do, no reason not to.
How to attackers win then? Strategy. It's always it. Defenders need the sheer force ll pulled into one area. Attackers need the strategy because they siply can't pull the force together the same. Alliances are a huge thing in this game; use them to your advantage, don't jus' go on a one man conquest.