Who would win?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wpack10

Umm SW ships have shields too. And Star Wars easily win.

---

SW ships only have deflector shields for traveling at high speeds.

ST ships have navigation (deflector) shields as well as defensive shields.

SW ships also use laser canons as weaponry. There's an episode of TNG where the Enterprise comes across a ship armed with lasers and it is stated by Picard that their weapons "won't even penetrate our navigation shielding."

Enterprise would bring uber pwnage on the entire Imperial Fleet.

Imperial Mk II Star Destroyer: Over a mile long. Tractor beams to pull stuff in. Enough weaponry to annihilate it, really, really fast. 72 starfighters on board for interceptions.

Enterprise: Small. Wimpy. Unable to flee.


Who do YOU think?

If you move all power to forward deflectors, where, might I ask, are you getting the power to fire the lasers?
Exactly, thank you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zenrax

Imperial Mk II Star Destroyer: Over a mile long. Tractor beams to pull stuff in. Enough weaponry to annihilate it, really, really fast. 72 starfighters on board for interceptions.

Enterprise: Small. Wimpy. Unable to flee.


Who do YOU think?

---

All with laser weapons and no shields

Refer to my above post.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BBQ_Sauce

SW ships only have deflector shields for traveling at high speeds.

ST ships have navigation (deflector) shields as well as defensive shields.

SW ships also use laser canons as weaponry. There's an episode of TNG where the Enterprise comes across a ship armed with lasers and it is stated by Riker that their weapons "won't even penetrate our navigation shielding."

Enterprise would bring uber pwnage on the entire Imperial Fleet.

---

SW ships have deflector shields for ANYTHING. The Enterprise can pound away with its puny little cannons until the cows come home, and nothing will happen. Even if the lasers don't work, they have massive batteries of concussion missiles, and they could just pull the Enterprise into their hanger bay and board it, just like the Tantive IV.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zenrax

SW ships have deflector shields for ANYTHING. The Enterprise can pound away with its puny little cannons until the cows come home, and nothing will happen. Even if the lasers don't work, they have massive batteries of concussion missiles, and they could just pull the Enterprise into their hanger bay and board it, just like the Tantive IV.

---

Ok, let's say the Star Destroyer has the advantage in weapons and shields (which it doesn't)

The Enterprise still has the advantage in speed and doesn't have to go into some wimpy "hyperspace" to go FTL

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4ijDlbvAxw

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BBQ_Sauce

Ok, let's say the Star Destroyer has the advantage in weapons and shields (which it doesn't)

The Enterprise still has the advantage in speed and doesn't have to go into some wimpy "hyperspace" to go FTL

---

Have you even SEEN Star Wars? Did you think that in the opening scene, they just flew into the Star Destroyer and were slaughtered for FUN? No. They were trapped in a tractor beam...

And HOW, in your wildest fantasies, could the Enterprise have an offensive or defensive advantage? It's like a guy in a bathtub with a pistol vs. the Yamato!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Zenrax

Have you even SEEN Star Wars? Did you think that in the opening scene, they just flew into the Star Destroyer and were slaughtered for FUN? No. They were trapped in a tractor beam...

And HOW, in your wildest fantasies, could the Enterprise have an offensive or defensive advantage? It's like a guy in a bathtub with a pistol vs. the Yamato!

---

Phasers > laser canons

Quantum Torpedos > Concussion Missiles

Regenerative shields and ablative armor > deflector shields

Warp Drive > Hyperspace

Besides, you can't even get a lock with a tractor beam while the Enterprise's shields are up and those puny little laser canons can't even come close to penetrating it's shields.

ok eneterprise wins if it has data ...that settles it