Originally Posted by
ben975
Interesting concept but I don't think your even close to the correct formula, huge losses for the attacker often results in items as well, even if they kill very little defending troops. Your formula doesn't account for that.
Alongside that, I have over 20,000 cents worth of the valid items, meaning killing even 5k of my archers would result in a 90% chance of an item, yet despite having been scout bombed 100s of times with open gates my opponents have rarely got items from me (unless you assume they lie to me about not getting items, seems somewhat unlikely as people would tend to brag about the opposite)
Also, on your descriptions about the Jaq attack you mention a "1000 range bonus" for cav in "special circumstances". You should read Bradys sticked guide, the +200 range theory discussed there makes much more sense and consistently explains every battle report presented so far.