Great Military Leader Versus (Game)

[King Dylan]

I think we should adjust this to assume technologically and numerically equal forces. Obviously, Patton would beat Genghis Khan, simply because arrows and swords don't hurt tanks. But give each of them cavalry, and it changes the whole situation.

Yeah. That's why I said we should match people up in the same time frame. :/

[Kalent]

Well, here's a match in the same time!

Zhuge Liang VS Sima Yi
Consider they have the same number of troops.

[jiah]

Sima Yi had a cooler name. He wins.

Arnold Shwartzennager vs Darth Vader............... I watch to many movies.

General Grievous vs. Darth VAder is what I like!

[kiteguthan]

Arnold would own Vader, and Vader would own Grevious.
You can't scratch the Terminatah!

Fredrick the Great (Of Germany) vs. Queen Isabella (Of Spain)

[Kalent]

I wish that people would stop just choosing "People they heard of" or "People who have a cooler name", and actually take the effort to look up the actual person to learn, and give your opinion.
Or else this has no point.

[Elana*]

Arnold would own Vader, and Vader would own Grevious.
You can't scratch the Terminatah!

Fredrick the Great (Of Germany) vs. Queen Isabella (Of Spain)

hard choice...~thinks~

i THINK that federick would win...(but who knows? women tend to scratch the win frm battles)

~indecision~

[Asmo]

Fredrick the Great (Of Germany) vs. Queen Isabella (Of Spain)

Assuming this Isa 2 of recent

Queen Isabella was ruthless but her aims were always political. She had a lot of good commander and generals but they took power from her so Fredrick wins by default here.

Nicholas II Vz. Archduke Francis Ferdinand

Bonus points for answer to this for sure

[Elana*]

umm i dont know generals so well....

Napoleon Bonaparte against....Ivan the Terrible

[VictusDeus]

I can't seem to find much of a reason to pick either one, Nicholas II or Archduke Francis Ferdinand, I would have to say neither is what you would consider militarily oriented which means they would have had to rely on Generals in that case I would have to go with the Archduke since Nicholas II was a horrible leader when it came to matters of both military and state, during his time as Czar in Russia it seems like he almost was trying to get himself assassinated.

[Wildor]

umm i dont know generals so well....

Napoleon Bonaparte against....Ivan the Terrible

If you don't have anything worthwhile to contribute, stick to the bar please.


A better approach to this is to pit one time allies against one another.

Example: Bradley vs Monty. Or Grant vs Sherman.