Hmm this is getting harder - particularly if over-playing is part of it...

What about:

Landslide by Fleetwood Mac

Fire and Rain by James Taylor

What do you say by Reba

Falling Awake by Gary Jules

Lost in this Moment by Big and Rich

Disarm by Smashing Pumpkins

True Colors by Cyndi Lauper

There's a list - i wanna know what people think --- personally I can't see people saying "ugh, I hate those songs" - but maybe i just have a completely different music taste?