I don't normally visit this section but here are my thoughts about this ruckus:

1. That GameEnder deserves some credit for his phract smack even if a lot of players could do it except for the lack of opportunity.
2. That GameEnder was still high on adrenaline at the time he posted his 'awesome' hit and probably changed his overall forum character after getting the disrespect that Cusheth normally delivers.
3. That Cusheth do have an inclination to only praise his own or his groupie and to say that he's not wrong (always?) is a partial manifestation and highly debatable.
4. That I agree with Kiki's observation about GameEnder's behavior (overly hyping and aggressive) though again, could be largely due to Cusheth's first post and/or his own real character showing its infamous side.
5. That GameEnder needs to settle down a bit and celebrate on his feat rather than engaging in an overly aggressive manner.
6. That challenging any or all won't still settle anything whether you'll actually win or not. Any decent player knows this game is almost all about being active & troops (resources and heroes). Very little about skills. I dont think you'll want to be known as the baddest player for being the most active. Or having the best heroes because you farm and pay. Or because you have the most troops. These days, anyone could always legitimately question you how you get the resources (whether by bot/alts or bug). None of the things I mentioned could further your case to prove your battle skills. I acted somewhat similarly when another alliance tried to paint what I strongly believed was just propaganda against my alliance. But I only challenged them to a theoretical battle to ultimately test each others' skills. Brute-force attack is not my thing and I don't have the luxury of sitting in front of the computer for several hours. That was also the time I started my first puzzle to challenged some resident posters here. Just trace my posts if you want to know since this not about me.
6. That I honestly believe that the main parties involved in this fracas know the battle mechanics though there could be one more creative than the other. It's like a lot of people know how to play Chess, understand how the pieces move. But not everyone will have the same level of creativity or skills. Evony is a lot less complicated than chess though and there is very little permutations than you can get out of it. Much less for unique or brilliant combos.
7. That I can't tell whether GameEnder is the first to use a particular wave http://www.evonyurl.com/nawr1c
while I don't actually approve of its efficiency, I could say that he could be the first to actually post it here. I could be wrong because I don't visit this section for the very reason that awesome hits can be accomplished by anyone who knows the battle mechanics. It's only the opportunity that is the concern.

That being said, I do have some observations with regards to the actual Evony battles since GameEnder said he will be coming with his own guide that perhaps, he will make adjustments to his guide if he finds my observations useful.

Exhibit A. http://www.evonyurl.com/nawr1c
Exhibit B. http://www.evonyurl.com/la4crk

In each battle, you missed adding a transporter which could only improve the attacking rams ability to do more damage without affecting how the troops will move on the battlefield. Not that the transporters could actually improve in your battles but since you have shown practically the same set of troops and proportion, I'm inclined to believe that this could be one of your standard combos which could only lead many players, especially your followers, to believe that that is a smart thing to do. The troop combo as well as the proportion (size or amount) to use depends on the opposing troops. Im sure you know that the key is to position the right troops at the right spot.

When doing a series of waves (like you did), it's better to use consistently good waves than using what you might think an awesome wave but sets you up to a few poor followup waves. You did admit that it took you 5 or 6 cav waves to clear all his layers which completely negated whatever gains you think you might have in the first wave (ex A).

On exhibit B, you missed sending enough missile units to take out the few ATs. I also believe you overly exaggerated your claims that it would normally take 5 waves of cavs just to highlight your wave and insinuating as if there are no other good options to be made. That probably earned you negative points in the eyes of objective readers of this thread.

On your last wave, I don't think you've applied excal on your hero when you accomplished it.

Overall, you did well. You were brave enough to use such a high level hero without fear that the opposite player had already logged on and could be setting you up already.