Mafia IX

[Alusair]

Just get one of your 4 friends to "vouch" for you...

*cough* avoiding the question *cough*

You listed only 2 of 4 possible options. If I'm one of those missing roles, I couldn't answer without being forced to lie, which you could then use against me.

[Server139Player]

I think people are going to believe what they want to believe as far as what I claim to be. I said I was a civ that other game and got lynched anyway. I think I'd need to have other people vouch for me for it to be believable, but if they do, what if they become the next mafia targets? I'd rather not have that happen.

Ironically because of that last game, if you said you were a civ this game I would 100% believe you and back you up in any way that i could. As it is this game I'm not going to vote for you because of my bad actions against you in the last game, even if they were of the best of intentions... So I'll stick with deathslayr for being mean.

[Hehe]

Yeah, but you aren't...And we both know it

[Emma6]

Deathslayr - 2 - (s139p, Emma)
JPA32 - 1 - (Boleslav)
Furr - 1 - (Mati2)
Alusair - 9 - (Hehe, Gr8, Morgan, furrr, Grito, Reas, estrickland89, JPA32, jorbaud)
Hehe - 2 - (Alusair, gotti)

going back to original vote

[rasterbee]

Ok, so I'm new to this but I don't believe Alu. She's been turning into a troll lately and I don't believe her wall of text is designed to do anything but further confuse people.

If she isn't mafia, then we'll definitely find out 1 mafia member, and by looking back at who was arguing with/against who we can probably easily determine more.
([EDIT AFTER REVIEW OF ALL COMMENTS] If we kill Alu and she is a civilian, then we know Hehe is mafia AND Morgan. And I'd go so far as to say furrr is most likely mafia too.) Even if Alu is an extremely valuable role and a civilian and we kill her, there will be a dead mafia player next round.

Yes/no? I haven't voted yet, obviously.

Also, I refuse to believe anything Bole says unless it is air tight logical and impossible to refute.

[Emma6]

Ok, so I'm new to this but I don't believe Alu. She's been turning into a troll lately and I don't believe her wall of text is designed to do anything but further confuse people.

If she isn't mafia, then we'll definitely find out 1 mafia member, and by looking back at who was arguing with/against who we can probably easily determine more.
([EDIT AFTER REVIEW OF ALL COMMENTS] If we kill Alu and she is a civilian, then we know Hehe is mafia AND Morgan. And I'd go so far as to say furrr is most likely mafia too.) Even if Alu is an extremely valuable role and a civilian and we kill her, there will be a dead mafia player next round.

Yes/no? I haven't voted yet, obviously.

Also, I refuse to believe anything Bole says unless it is air tight logical and impossible to refute.

i cannot believe i am saying this, but i just saw logic in a rasterbee post.

[rasterbee]

Emma, nobody cares what you think.

EDIT: MY VOTE

Alu has to die. No matter what role and power, Alu's death will benefit the civilians. If she is mafia, she's dead and Hehe and Morgan can be trusted. If she's civilian, she's dead who cares what her power is...Hehe and Morgan will have given themselves away as mafia. I don't even know what to make of gotti's comment where she said she was mafia. I don't see how that could possibly benefit anyone. If she's a civilian and lying that makes no sense. And if she's a mafia and telling the truth, that makes no sense either. I don't get it.

Deathslayr - 2 - (s139p, Emma)
JPA32 - 1 - (Boleslav)
Furr - 1 - (Mati2)
Alusair - 10 - (Hehe, Gr8, Morgan, furrr, Grito, Reas, estrickland89, JPA32, jorbaud, raster)
Hehe - 2 - (Alusair, gotti)

[Hehe]

Just like to say:

Morgan saw logic in what I was saying, and agreed with me because she didn't see a better option (and because we're "married"). When I am proved to be a Civ, Morgan is still not confirmed, and if, hypothetically, in a different game where Alusair was civ and I was mafia, Morgan agreeing with me would not confirm her as mafia...Just as at the end of this round, we can't be sure that she's civ, just because she agreed with me...That's not saying she's mafia, just unknown...

Just clearing up an error in your logic

[BS.]

Deathslayr - 1 - (s139p)
JPA32 - 1 - (Boleslav)
Furr - 1 - (Mati2)
Alusair - 13 - (Hehe, BS, Gr8, Morgan, furrr, Death, PIALPHA, Grito, Reas, estrickland89, JPA32, jorbaud, Emma)
Hehe - 2 - (Alusair, gotti)

[gottibabe1]

wait...

what if... alu and hehe are BOTH mafia!

Think about it... Mafia can't mob kill one another... but they sure can lynch each other...

what if this is all a set up... to get the civilians to trust a mafia... they will be destructible...