Yeah - the 10% rule is definitely having some negative consequences...

Obviously the defender should ALWAYS get a report - I mean they are being attacked, and your beacon tower tells you what's coming. Does it make sense that you have LESS information after the attack (get nothing because of the 10% rule) than before (see something because of beacon)?

And I agree - for large armies you should get a report. Attacking with 100k archers and getting no report is frustrating and I think unintended. It's good you can't scout with just 100 warriors now, but this was not the right way to go about fixing that problem.